
MINI-TENDER
OFFERS: TIPS FOR INVESTORS
Most investors welcome tender offers because they
frequently provide a rare opportunity to sell securities at a
premium above market price. Mini-tender offers (tender
offers for less than five percent of a company's stock) – have
been increasingly used to catch investors off guard. Many
investors who hear about mini-tender offers surrender their
securities without investigating the offer, assuming that the
price offered includes the premium usually present in larger,
traditional tender offers. They later learn that they cannot
withdraw from the offer and may end up selling their securities
at below-market prices.
If you've been asked to tender your securities, find out
first whether the offer is a mini-tender offer. Mini-tender
offers typically do not provide the same disclosure and
procedural protections that larger, traditional tender offers
provide. When a bidder makes a tender offer for more than five
percent of the company's shares, all of the SEC's tender offer
rules apply.
These rules require bidders to:
Disclose
important information about themselves
Disclose
the terms of the offer
File their offering
documents with the SEC
Provide the target
company and competing bidders with information about the
tender offer
The SEC rules give investors
important protections:
Change
their minds and withdraw from the transaction while the offer
remains open
Have
their shares accepted on a "pro rata" basis
Be
treated equally by the bidder
None of the above rules apply to mini-tender offers.
The only rules that encompass mini-tender offers are Section
14(e) of the Securities Exchange Act and Regulation 14E.
These rules provide that bidders
must:
Not
engage in fraud or deceptive practices
Hold
open tender offers for minimum time periods
Make
prompt payment to investors after the offer closes
Regulation 14E also requires the target company to state
its position about the offer by recommending that investors
accept or reject the offer. The company may also state that it
remains neutral. However, bidders in mini-tender offers don't
have to notify the target, the company may not even know about
the offer.
Investors need to scrutinize mini-tender offers carefully.
Some bidders make mini-tender offers at below-market prices,
hoping that they will catch investors off guard if the investors
do not compare the offer price to the current market price.
Others make mini-tender offers at a premium, betting that the
market price will rise before the offer closes and then
extending the offer until it does or improperly canceling if it
doesn't.
With most mini-tender offers, investors typically feel
pressured to tender their shares quickly without having solid
information about the offer or the people behind it. And they've
been shocked to learn that they generally cannot withdraw from
mini-tender offers.
Here are the steps you should take
if you are asked to sell your stock, bonds, limited partnership
interests, or other securities through a mini-tender offer:
Find out whether the offer is a
mini-tender offer.
Most bidders won't use the term mini-tender offer.
Instead, they may call it a "Solicitation to
Purchase". Ask the bidder (or your broker) what
percentage the bidder seeks to purchase. If the answer is less
than five percent, you're dealing with a mini-tender offer, and
you should proceed with caution.
Get a copy of the offering document.
Do not make an investment decision until you read the
offer disclosure carefully.
Determine whether the bidder has
adequate financing.
Some bidders make mini-tender offers because they can
do so at virtually no cost. These individuals often do not have
the financing necessary to purchase the shares in the offer.
Before you surrender your securities in a mini-tender offer, ask
tough questions about the bidder's ability to pay once the offer
closes.
Identify the current market price for
your securities.
For stock, you can get price information from many
normal sources. For bonds and limited partnerships, you
may need to talk with your broker/adviser because these prices
may be hard to find. For limited partnerships, contact the
general partner to get a list of firms that buy and sell the
limited partnership.
Find out the "final" tender
offer price after all deductions are taken.
In some tender offers, you may get a lower price because
deductions are taken from the tender offer price for dividend
payments. Some bidders in mini-tender offers fail to disclose
clearly that certain fees or expenses may also be deducted from
the offer price.
Ask when you'll be paid for the
shares you tender.
Bidders in mini-tender offers sometimes fail to provide
prompt payment, sometimes delaying for weeks or months. Before
you tender your shares, be sure to find out when the bidder will
pay you for your shares.
Consult with your broker or other
financial adviser.
Make sure you understand the terms of the tender offer before
tendering your shares. Ask for any additional written
information that may be available.
If you want to sell your shares,
determine where you can get your best price.
Check all your alternatives for selling your securities.
For instance, compare how much you will receive if you sell
through your broker versus the tender offer.
Remember that once you agree to a
mini-tender offer, you are probably locked in.
If the tender offer is for less than five percent of the
company's stock, exercise extreme caution. Unlike other tender
offers, you generally cannot change your mind after you
have tendered your shares in a mini-tender offer, even if the
offer hasn't yet closed. In addition, the bidder can extend the
tender offer without giving you the right to withdraw your
shares.
If you've run into trouble with a mini-tender offer, act
promptly. By law, you only have a limited time to take legal
action.